13 Pizza Places In Tampa Florida

pizza places in tampa fl featured image
Table of Contents

Tampa, Florida: A thriving metropolis on the Gulf Coast known for diverse cuisine and rich history. Boasts a variety of pizza places for traditionalists and flavor enthusiasts.

Discover 13 notable pizza places in Tampa, Florida, each offering distinctive flavors and experiences for food enthusiasts in the city.

The selection process considered factors like ingredients, preparation techniques, and overall dining experience. These pizza places in Tampa range from traditional Neapolitan and Sicilian styles to contemporary global-inspired approaches.

The list was curated to include affordable and accessible options, ensuring readers can explore Tampa’s pizza scene regardless of budget or location.

Stay tuned for a comprehensive guide showcasing Tampa’s exceptional pizzerias and what makes each one unique in the city’s competitive culinary scene.

Eddie And Sam’s N.Y Pizza

Image Credit: Thatssotampa

Eddie and Sam’s N.Y Pizza, located at 203 E Twiggs St in Tampa, Florida, is renowned for its authentic New York-style pizza.

Established with the aim of bringing genuine New York pizza to downtown Tampa, this establishment has become a local favorite among residents and visitors alike.

The characteristic wide, thin, and foldable slices associated with New York-style pizza can be traced back to Gennaro Lombardi, who was granted the first license to sell pizza in the United States in 1905.

One factor contributing to Eddie and Sam’s N.Y Pizza’s authenticity is their usage of imported New York City tap water when preparing dough for their pizzas.

It is believed that the unique flavor of New York-style crusts results from the minerals found within the city’s tap water supply.

By replicating these conditions, Eddie and Sam’s N.Y Pizza delivers an experience that transports patrons straight to Spring Street in lower Manhattan where American pizza history began.

Eddie and Sam’s N.Y Pizza offers not only delicious food but also excellent customer service which contributes to its loyal following.

Operating primarily during lunchtime on weekends and evenings on weekdays (closed on Mondays and Tuesdays), this establishment caters to both dine-in and takeout customers, making it a popular choice for various dining preferences.

Eddie And Sam’s N.Y Pizza stands out among Tampa’s pizza establishments for its commitment to tradition, offering an authentic taste of America’s culinary heritage.

Due Amici Pizza & Pasta Bar

Image Credit: Tripadvisor

Located in the heart of Ybor City, a historic neighborhood in Tampa, Florida, Due Amici Pizza & Pasta Bar offers an authentic Italian experience to its patrons.

This family-run establishment offers handcrafted, delicious dishes made from fresh ingredients. Along with a warm ambiance, customers receive exceptional service, creating memorable dining experiences.

At Due Amici, every dish is meticulously prepared with love and expertise. The kitchen takes great pride in their homemade sauces which perfectly complement the flavors of their various offerings.

Their standout pizza dough is freshly made daily, expertly hand-spun, and generously topped with delicious ingredients. The menu also offers tempting pasta dishes crafted from time-honored, generational recipes.

Due Amici’s late-night hours make it a popular spot for locals and tourists seeking scrumptious food after exploring Tampa’s vibrant nightlife or attending nearby events. This cozy restaurant has become a staple in Ybor City’s culinary scene.

Due Amici delivers on all fronts, offering thin-crust pizzas with flavorful toppings and comforting pasta dishes with savory sauces. A must-visit dining destination in bustling Tampa, Florida.

Viva Napoli Restaurant & Pizzeria

Image Credit: Otstatic

Viva Napoli Restaurant & Pizzeria, located at 4301 W El Prado Blvd in Tampa, Florida, offers authentic Italian cuisine. With delicious pizza and pasta dishes, patrons can savor the flavors of Naples in a warm atmosphere. Plan ahead as their hours vary throughout the week.

Don’t miss the dining experience at Viva Napoli, a must-visit for locals and tourists. Guests are welcomed into an inviting ambiance that sets the stage for a satisfying meal. The menu offers traditional Neapolitan recipes crafted from fresh, locally sourced, and imported Italian ingredients.

Pizza enthusiasts will delight in trying their hand-tossed pies cooked in a wood-fired oven – an essential component of true Neapolitan-style pizza. As this culinary gem continues to expand its reach within the Tampa Bay area, many satisfied customers have shared glowing reviews about their experiences at Viva Napoli Restaurant & Pizzeria.

Viva Napoli has secured its place among Tampa’s top pizza joints with outstanding service, mouthwatering meals, and a relaxed setting. It offers an unforgettable Italian dining experience with exceptional customer care, pleasing even the most discerning palates.

Hampton Station Pizzeria

Image Credit: Cloudfront

Hampton Station Pizzeria in Tampa offers more than just delicious pizzas. Located in a unique setting, it doubles as an old-school local Seminole Heights bar, providing culinary delights, entertainment, and ambiance.

The restaurant can be found at 5921 N Nebraska Ave, Tampa, FL 33604, United States. Operating out of a converted gas station, it offers a craft beer bar experience with over 50 microbrews and European beers to please every discerning palate.

At this one-of-a-kind location, customers can enjoy live music and DJ performances on select nights while indulging in their favorite brews and mouth-watering pizzas.

It has varying operating hours: Mon-Wed: 3 PM – 11 PM, Thu: 3 PM-midnight, Fri: 2:30 PM-midnight, Sat: 12 PM-midnight, Sun: 12 PM – 10 PM. Perfect for weekday dinners or weekend hangouts with friends.

Hampton Station Pizzeria provides residents of Tampa with a distinctive dining experience where they can savor scrumptious pizzas alongside quality craft beers in a lively atmosphere.

Tampa Pizza Company

Image Credit: Pressablecdn

Tampa Pizza Company is a renowned establishment in Tampa, Florida. Its widespread acclaim comes from using fresh ingredients and crafting delectable pizzas for diverse palates. With unique toppings and combinations, every customer can find something enjoyable.

For classic slice lovers, Tampa Pizza Company’s must-try dish is the Thin Crust Square Pizza. It features a crisp yet chewy crust, serving as the perfect base for mouthwatering toppings like pepperoni or mushrooms.

It offers specialty pies with adventurous flavors, featuring unconventional ingredients like artichokes, feta cheese, or buffalo chicken. Each creation showcases exceptional skill and finesse, guaranteeing memorable pizza experiences for all tastes and preferences.

Tampa Pizza Company has earned esteem in the community during its five years as a Slice partner. Offering curbside pickup and accepting credit cards, this local gem caters to both gastronomical desires and practical needs.

Visitors and locals alike are encouraged to experience firsthand what makes Tampa Pizza Company so beloved by those fortunate enough to have sampled their offerings.

Gourmet Pizza Company

Image Credit: Patch

Gourmet Pizza Company, a culinary gem in Tampa’s Hyde Park neighborhood, has been delighting diners for over two decades. With innovative and mouthwatering creations, they offer an exceptional dining experience that promotes health-conscious choices, while maintaining a steadfast commitment to quality.

The eclectic menu features fresh, locally sourced ingredients expertly crafted into delectable gourmet pizzas that challenge tradition. The warm and charming ambiance makes it ideal for casual gatherings and special occasions.

Patrons can enjoy a cozy interior or dine on the inviting outdoor patio. The extensive selection of unique pies includes inventive combinations like Thai chicken curry, Mediterranean medley, and dessert-inspired options. Vegetarian and vegan customers are catered to with diverse offerings, showcasing the restaurant’s dedication to inclusivity and customer satisfaction.

Gourmet Pizza Company is synonymous with excellence among Tampa Pizza enthusiasts. Their commitment to crafting inspired dishes with freshness and sustainability sets them apart. Countless accolades throughout their storied history highlight their dedication to culinary excellence.

For an unforgettable gastronomic adventure, look no further than this extraordinary establishment. Each visit promises a redefined gourmet pizza experience unlike any other.

Grimaldi’s Pizzeria

Image Credit: Stackpathcdn

Grimaldi’s Pizzeria, located at 218 Westshore Plaza, is a family-friendly restaurant that boasts an upscale New York-themed ambiance and a unique coal-fired brick oven method for crafting their pizzas.

With over a century-old tradition originating in Brooklyn, Grimaldi’s Pizzeria has built a solid reputation among pizza enthusiasts who seek authentic tastes not found in conventional oven-baked pizzas. The secret to Grimaldi’s delectable offerings lies in their use of fresh ingredients and hand-tossed dough made daily on-site according to a confidential recipe.

With signature Coal-Fired Brick Ovens, this pizzeria captures traditional pizza-making techniques. Exceptional service and a warm atmosphere create an unforgettable dining experience, appealing to both locals and visitors.

Grimaldi’s Pizzeria is open seven days a week. Weekdays: 11 AM – 9 PM (Friday until 10 PM). Weekends: 11 AM – 10 PM (Saturday) and 11 AM – 9 PM (Sunday).

This renowned pizzeria offers more than just delicious pizzas. It provides an authentic culinary journey reminiscent of classic New York-style eateries, right in Tampa Bay.

Sally O’Neal’s Pizza Hotline

Image Credit: Yelpcdn

Sally O’Neal’s Pizza Hotline is an ideal destination in Tampa, Florida, offering a wide variety of delicious pizzas and Italian dishes. Conveniently located on South Howard Avenue, it satisfies cravings with ease.

Operating hours are from 11:00 AM until 9:00 PM Sundays through Thursdays, while extended operating hours up to 10:00 PM cater to the weekend crowds on Fridays and Saturdays.

Sally O’Neal’s Pizza Hotline offers gluten-free pizza crusts and pasta options. However, individuals with Celiac Disease should be cautious as the kitchen may have traces of gluten-containing ingredients, increasing the risk of cross-contamination.

The contact number is (813) 251-0220 which can be utilized by potential patrons seeking additional information or reservations.

Sally O’Neal’s Pizza Hotline offers authentic Italian cuisine in Tampa. However, diners should consider potential allergen concerns related to gluten content. Enjoy the delicious offerings while being mindful of dietary restrictions.

New York New York Pizza

Image Credit: Tripadvisor

New York New York Pizza, located in the heart of Ybor City at 1512 E 7th Ave, this pizzeria has made a name for itself with its delicious and authentic New York-style pies.

With an extensive menu that includes not only pizza but also pasta dishes, calzones, strombolis, and even burgers, there is something to satisfy every craving.

New York New York Pizza stands out with its commitment to high-quality ingredients and traditional cooking methods. Fresh dough, house-made sauce, and premium toppings are baked in brick ovens, resulting in a perfect balance of crispy crust and gooey cheese for an unforgettable dining experience.

Customers can choose between ordering whole pies or by-the-slice options making it convenient for both larger parties or those seeking a quick meal on the go.

This local gem caters to patrons’ diverse needs through delivery services and catering options.

Open seven days a week with late-night hours until 11:45 PM Monday through Saturday (closing at 10:00 PM on Sundays), one can indulge in their favorite dish any day of the week without time constraints.

Diners at New York New York Pizza, whether dining in or taking advantage of additional amenities are guaranteed to be impressed by the quality and authenticity of every bite.

Abc Pizza House

Image Credit: Imgix

Distinguished by its exceptional service and delectable menu options, ABC Pizza House has become a beloved dining establishment among Tampa residents.

The enticing aroma of freshly baked pizzas and the perfect combination of flavorful toppings and high-quality ingredients await. With multiple convenient locations, patrons can enjoy their favorite pizza without long wait times or overcrowded spaces.

ABC Pizza House offers an extensive variety of dishes to satisfy all cravings. In addition to mouthwatering pizzas, they serve scrumptious side dishes like French fries. The pizzeria also caters to different dietary needs with gluten-free crusts and vegan cheese options.

As a partner of Slice for half a decade, ABC Pizza House has consistently demonstrated its commitment to serving its community through seamless curbside pickup services and irresistible deals on meals.

Remarkable features at ABC Pizza House have fostered customer loyalty and a sense of unity in the neighborhood. Convenient credit card payments during checkout enhance the dining experience, solidifying their reputation as an exemplary eatery in Tampa, Florida.

Bavaro’s Pizza Napoletana & Pastaria

Image Credit: Heraldtribune

Bavaro’s Pizza Napoletana & Pastaria, is a restaurant deeply rooted in tradition and authenticity.

Established as Florida’s first traditional Neapolitan pizzeria in 2009 by the passionate and hardworking Bavaro family, this establishment has grown exponentially over the years.

Despite their growth, they have remained true to their core values of providing high-quality Italian cuisine that allows guests to experience the love and energy found around their own dinner table.

Bavaro’s maintains authentic Neapolitan pizza culture with hand-crafted wood-fired brick ovens, century-old yeast cultures and recipes, and top-quality ingredients imported from Italy.

Apart from their delectable pizzas, they also offer homemade pasta sauces crafted using time-honored recipes.

Anna-Maria Bavaro introduced a unique offering by repurposing excess sauce from a canceled event, allowing loyal patrons to bring the taste of Bavaro’s into their homes.

With four locations in Tampa Bay, St. Petersburg, Sarasota, and Tampa International Airport, Bavaro’s maintains its reputation for exceptional dining experiences, focusing on quality food and warm hospitality.

Each location offers consistently welcoming atmospheres where guests can indulge in mouthwatering dishes made with care and passion.

Thus, those seeking both delicious Italian fare and a genuine connection to culinary heritage should look no further than Bavaro’s Pizza Napoletana & Pastaria.

Palazzo Pizza

Image Credit: Brightspotcdn

Palazzo Pizza in Tampa, Florida offers a unique fusion of Italian authenticity and Boston inspiration. Located at 1818 West Platt Street, it has become a popular choice for both locals and visitors.

Upon entering Palazzo Pizza, patrons are greeted with an atmosphere that combines the best elements of contemporary design and timeless charm. The restaurant prides itself on using only fresh, never frozen ingredients in all their recipes – a testament to their commitment to quality and flavor.

Palazzo Pizza combines traditional family recipes with the innovative techniques of Nick Varano, resulting in creatively crafted dishes that preserve the essence of Italian cuisine.

For a memorable dining experience in Tampa’s evolving culinary scene, Palazzo Pizza is a must-visit. With exceptional customer service and delectable menu offerings, it consistently receives rave reviews from satisfied customers.

Whether one is craving classic Margherita or experimenting with more adventurous toppings, Palazzo Pizza ensures every slice will be unforgettable.

Mangia Bene Pizzeria

Image Credit: Restaurant

Emphasizing the significance of Mangia Bene Pizzeria as a culinary landmark in Tampa, Florida, it is essential to explore the various aspects that contribute to its popularity.

Serving authentic Italian cuisine with an emphasis on pizza, Mangia Bene Pizzeria demonstrates consistency and quality across their menu items.

A Slice partner for 9 years, this local business has managed to establish itself as a favorite among residents and visitors alike.

One of the standout features at Mangia Bene Pizzeria is their Thick Crust Sicilian Square Pizza, which consistently receives high praise from patrons.

This particular dish showcases the pizzeria’s dedication to using fresh ingredients and mastering traditional cooking techniques.

Customers can also find satisfaction in soda offerings that complement each meal perfectly.

As such, even those with large appetites will not be left wanting after dining at this establishment.

As part of the broader community, Mangia Bene Pizzeria understands the importance of convenience for their clientele.

To address this need, they offer curbside pickup services that streamline the takeout process without compromising on food quality or customer experience.

Mangia Bene Pizzeria cultivates strong ties with its audience by accepting credit card payments and maintaining an active presence on social media platforms. This fosters an atmosphere where delicious food can thrive.

Frequently Asked Questions

Naples, Italy, is widely regarded as the birthplace of pizza and is renowned for its authentic Neapolitan-style pizza.

The ranking of Tampa pizza establishments can vary depending on individual preferences and reviews on platforms like TripAdvisor. You can check the provided link for up-to-date rankings and reviews of pizza places in Tampa.

The exact number of pizza places in Florida is difficult to determine, as new ones open and close regularly. However, Florida is home to a wide variety of pizzerias, ranging from local favorites to well-known chains.

The most famous pizza in Naples is the Neapolitan pizza, which features a thin, soft, and chewy crust topped with simple ingredients like San Marzano tomatoes, fresh mozzarella cheese, basil, and olive oil. It is highly regarded for its traditional and authentic preparation.

Similar blogs

Scroll to Top